Human suffering in Gaza, and elsewhere?
The current bout of fighting between Israel and Gaza raises old issues of the economic poverty amongst the Palestinians.
And now this week’s bombing, which has resulted in tens of lost lives, makes it easy for outside news agencies to highlight these woes. Sky TV has reported the suffering from a local hospital. The BBC has shown ample footage of the wounded being carried around and other collateral damage. The NGOs are have issued a string of complaints regarding Israel’s actions.
Also this week, at least 50 bodies were found in Iraq. The UN reported that civilian casualties in Afghanistan are up 17%. And the Ebola epidemic in Africa is slaying hundreds. So, if these issues barely rank a mention amongst the educated world media, I begun to wonder if the ‘gabble from Gaza’ had also succeeded in hiding a secondary level of suffering far closer to home.
However good reporters are, we know that they cannot portray a complete story in a two and a half minute clip. Sky omitted to mention that Gaza children continue to be accepted and treated in Israeli hospitals. The BBC has been forced to admit that in its rush to put out stories, facts have become distorted in places. And not for the first time, the NGOs have accepted the sanctimonious rhetoric of the ‘underdog’ in their rush to condemn Israel without due concern for the facts. Again, is there another story?
Lets us accept for now the stats of the Palestinian Ministry of Health that tens have been killed, including women and children. It is not clear to me, how they died. Do these same figures include Hamas soldiers killed in their own tunnels or taken out by Israeli gunfire? As for the bombings, by whom? It is known fact that up to a third of all Kassam rockets do not make it out of Gaza, falling back on the same population that launched them. Is that not a crime against humanity?
Next, if the population of Gaza is around 3 million, there are just over 8 million in Israel, of which about 75% is Jewish. Now, the improved Kassam missiles can reach about 80% of the population in the Holy Land. Actually, one landed last night in Beitunia, close to the house of President Abbas!
This means that by attacking Israel, Hamas is waging war against nearly three times the numbers of people in its own territory, highly disproportionate. (And these people have between 15 to 90 seconds to take cover before the rocket lands.) Further, as Hamas leaders boast, the Kassams are directed at civilians, where as Israel is aiming at military targets. Another crime that the International Court of Justice prefers to ignore?
As I wrote last week, Gaza is suffering. While Hamas invested in a large underground (literally) military infrastructure, the leadership has lacked the money to pay its own followers. Resources have been channeled into weapons that kill rather than towards the creation and protection of life. If a different path had been chosen, then
Palestinian firms could be natural partners for Israeli companies – and others – looking to export to the larger Arab markets, notably Saudi Arabia, Egypt and Iraq. The nascent Palestinian technology sector would find an experienced and willing partner in next-door Israel, with its highly developed technology industry. Israeli venture capital firms could provide much-needed financing, support, and know-how to export-oriented Palestinian entrepreneurs.
Hamas has chosen a separate path, wrecking havoc on everyone, starting with its own. This is not a story about fighting in Gaza. This is a war inflicted on civilians of all religions by an Islamic leadership whose human values are deformed, putrid and vile.
The fact that the greater media refuses or is unable to recognise this wider picture concerns me. Ben Cohen has written how the Palestinians have hijacked the language of Auschwitz “to maintain their position in the Western conscience as the world’s most downtrodden nation“. Howard Jacobson observes that Israel’s critics have adopted the language of anti-semites without even realizing it. He defines this as the “gradual habituation to the language of loathing. Passed from the culpable to the unwary and back again. And soon, before you know it…….”
Gaza is suffering? Yes, and because of Hamas. And that misery is passed on in disproportional numbers to its neighbours. If only the Palestinians had a leadership that genuinely cared about human morals. And the world press has a duty to all to find a way to convey that message.
0 comments